How to test your differentiator


​

How to Test Your Differentiator

Your differentiator should force a decision.

It should tell the market:

Choose our way or the highway.

And by highway, of course, I mean your competitors' dumb-ass way of doing things.

That's what makes a differentiator great.

Not being the best. Not caring for your customers. Not quality. Not personality. Not your team. Not anything your ideal customers expect from a business they pay.

You want something that makes them choose YOU.

But how do you know if your differentiator actually forces a decision?

Simple. Run it through the Opposite Test.

The Opposite Test

This is a relatively easy but powerful test β€” and one I do with every single client.

Running it is simple.

  1. Take your differentiator
  2. Write down its opposite
  3. Ask yourself: would anyone pay for the opposite?

If the answer is NO, you don't have a differentiator.

You're trying to prop up a basic expectation customers have of buying from anyone.

Let's look at a few examples.

Being the Best

Most B2B service companies, especially those in the industrial or manufacturing space, try to differentiate on being the best.

Let's run it through the Opposite Test:

  1. Our differentiator: Being the best
  2. The opposite: Being the worst
  3. Answer: No one would pay for the worst option

It doesn't pass the test.

Because no one in their right mind would actively search for the worst solution, the worst quality, or the worst business to work with.

Caring about our Customers

The next most popular differentiator is the claim that a business actually cares about their customers.

This one is so prevalent that a local tire repair shop is running ads on Hulu about it.

Their message: We're different because we care about our customers.

Let's run it through the Opposite Test:

  1. Our differentiator: We care about our customers
  2. The opposite: We hate our customers
  3. Answer: No one would pay for that

It doesn't pass the test.

No one in their right mind searches for a vendor that hates their customers, treats them like sh*t, and hopes they fail.

Go Beyond Expectations

Differentiators that fail the Opposite Test are not truly different.

They are basic expectations people have of giving businesses money.

Think about it.

Your ideal customers expect something from you when they pay:

  • You'll provide excellent quality
  • You'll care about their success
  • You'll deliver on your promise
  • You won't be a d*ck
  • You'll deliver results

Proping those expectations up as differentiators communicates the wrong message:

We don't have a viable reason for you to choose us. We just do the bare minimum and hope you're not smart enough to notice it.

Ouch.

Your ideal customers aren't that stupid.

Give them a real reason to choose you.

Run your differentiator through the Opposite Test.

If it passes, great! You likely have a differentiator that can generate revenue.

If it fails, start again.

The success of your business depends on it.

Until next week,

#SassyJason out.

✌🏼

Jason Vana

Founder & CEO @ Shft.agency​

P.S. Ready to attract a steady stream of dream clients? Our Onlyness Brand System provides you with the strategy you need to attract, convert, delight, and retain more of your best clients.

How We Help:

When you're ready, there are a few ways SHFT can help you:
​

  • ​Find Your Differentiation Email Course: uncover and own your unique value with this free course.
    ​
  • ​Onlyness Call: uncover your unique value and get suggestions on how to own it in your offer, content, and marketing in this 1.5-hour consultation with Sassy Jason.
    ​
  • ​Onlyness Brand System: done-for-you brand strategy, marketing strategy, and design packages. Perfect for startups, scaleups, and solopreneurs who want to attract, convert, delight, and keep their ideal customers.

Your Email Preferences:

Your email address is: Reader

​Update your preferences | Unsubscribe from all emails​

511 Summit Ave, West Chicago, Illinois 60185

SHFT Insider

Frameworks, exercises, and advice to create a brand strategy that attracts, converts, delights, and keeps your ideal customers.

Read more from SHFT Insider
one sentence brand strategy

One Sentence > 90 Pages Most founders don't understand strategy. They think it's a plan, a tactic, or a 90-page brand book that lists out everything they should and shouldn't do. Let me clear something up for you real quick: That's not a strategy. That's a damn mess. And often ends up buried in a filing cabinet somewhere, never to be seen again. No one refers to a strategy deck. Especially when creating content, Google ads, LinkedIn ads, planning a tradeshow or event, reworking a sales...

strategy is a decision

The One Decision that Rules Your Business Most founders don’t understand strategy. They see it as an elaborate plan β€” spreadsheets, brand decks, KPIs, and complex flowcharts that answer every question in your company. But that’s not a strategy. It’s a plan masquerading as a strategy, likely coming from someone who knows nothing about strategy. Think about it. Would 10 spreadsheets, a 90-page brand deck, a list of KPIs, and a series of flowcharts actually help you make decisions about your...

reverse roundabout sign

Not Differentiated? Try This Exercise Most businesses have something that makes them different. A process, a deliverable, a repeated result that could be owned in the market. But occasionally, I'll run across a business that legit has nothing that makes them different. Of the 145+ businesses I've worked with, only 25 fall into that category. No matter how hard we dug, there was just nothing different about them. What do you do in a case like that? Simple β€” you run the assumption reversal...